2000 Dodge Dakota Engine Overheating – Water Pump is New

Reader Question
I have a 2000 Dodge Dakota Sport and she is driving my insane. She was running hot, coolant pouring out. I took her in. Water pump replaced, radiator cap replaced.

She was doing fine and then out of the blue today she overheated while I was driving to work for the second time today. I was going about 70 and the temp maxed out. The gate guard said it smelled like the thermostat was stuck. I am going bald from the frustration. Please help me!!!


Hi there Laura,

Keep your hair intact, this is probably not as bad as you think. Since this last overheating issue happened at freeway speeds I would be highly suspect of a radiator that is clogged up with rust and junk at the bottom.

When radiators get stopped up, you can NOT “flush” the problem out. A new radiator is the only way to correct the issue….and a new after market radiator from your local auto parts place is half the price of a new radiator from Dodge.

A good mechanic should ALWAYS first pressure test the cooling system for leaks, if no leaks they can feel the radiator (when the engine is hot) and see if the top of the radiator is hotter than the bottom of the radiator…which would indicate a restriction. Most repair shops use these new infrared laser thermometers, which can really help pinpoint overheating restrictions.

Thermostats do fail, although it is not very common these days, but they are cheap and easy to replace if you want to just try a new one and see what happens.

BTW you should ALWAYS replace the thermostat when installing a new radiator. Make sure you keep an eye on the temperature gauge, you do not want this engine to overheat again or serious and costly engine damage can occur.

Austin Davis

Reader Follow Up Would the radiator have anything to do with my heater not blowing hot air also?

Hello Again Laura

Now we are getting somewhere. The heater core (the part that makes the heat inside your car) is basically a small radiator located inside your dashboard. The heater core needs the hot coolant from the engine to operate.

So if there is NO hot coolant inside the engine or the hot coolant flow is restricted somewhere and not flowing freely through the engine and heater core…..you will not get heat from the heater!

First things first, with the engine COLD, remove the radiator cap and look inside…top off with water if low or empty.

If you have to add more than a cup of water to the inside of the radiator then you have a coolant leak in the system somewhere and that is why I said every GOOD mechanic will first pressure test the cooling system for leaks before doing any repairs like a water pump.

It still sounds like you either have:

A. Don’t have enough coolant inside the radiator to keep the cool…thus you have a leak somewhere


B. You have a restriction somewhere…probably in the radiator which is not allowing coolant to flow throughout the engine and heater core.

Keep me posted will ya?
Austin Davis

Posted in: Over Heating

2 Comments on "2000 Dodge Dakota Engine Overheating – Water Pump is New"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Todd says:

    I have a 2000 dakota, it started overheating a couple days ago and i put coolant into it as it was low, thought i fixed it. but on my way to work the hose blew and I had to replace it and replaced thermostat as well. but it still overheats and coolant is still full. my brother thinks its the water pump. from reading various other comments and answeres Im thinking i need a new radiator. Please Help?

    • By Austin Davis says:

      If the engine seems to run hotter or overheats while on the freeway or at higher speeds than stop and go traffic, yes, a plugged up radiator is probably the culprit and will need to be replaced. Flushing does basically nothing. As I mentioned many times on this site, I always start with a cooling system pressure test first if there is low coolant levels in the radiator…it went somewhere.

      The water pump CAN fail, I have seen 1 where the impeller was rusted away so there was nothing left to circulate the coolant. This is extremely rare though. A water pump can leak, which is common but if you are not experiencing a leak, I would NOT suspect anything to be wrong with the pump.

Got Something to Say?